Club members please log in for more information.
19/11/26 – Could we all be a magistrate? – John Perry
John started by saying his plan was to talk for 15 minutes, then get us all involved in 3 case histories. Then introducing himself as a Civil Servant, who lived in Bingham, but had worked in Singapore; he generally ‘looked after’ Ministers. He’s been involved with Bingham Rugby Club, Chair of U3A Bingham, on the Notts Magistrate Bench for 20 years, generally working in the Criminal Court (rather than Youth or Family Court). One can be a magistrate from 18 to 75, but it is unpaid, but they are an integral part of the judicial system, with 95% of cases handled by the magistrates. The average age is 65 and there are 3 members for each session, being ‘judge and jury’ (although they do have legal advisors) and delivering the sentences. He believes the system started in the 14th Century when Edward the 3rd was King.
What doe they deal with? Traffic speeding, anti-social behaviour, stealing, domestic abuse, drinking and minor drugs issues, fly tipping, animal cruelty, school absenteeism. The range of pleas are guilty or not guilty (the bar is set high, so if a guilty verdict, it has to be clearly obvious). He then outlined sentencing guidelines to assist us with the case studies, but you do have to take into consideration any mitigating or aggravating factors: 1. minimum: discharge (although it could be conditional) 2. a fine- it must relate to the severity of the offence and their financial circumstances 3. Community order- this could involve ‘litter picking or decorating’ and can range from 40 to 300 hours 4. Prison – normally a suspended sentence (now 12 months max, but looking to increase to 2 years and there is rehabilitation or anger management training
The case histories: 1. Gladys Knight –70 yr old, stole a chicken, recently lost her husband, 2 previous convictions about 10 years ago. She pleads guilty. The general consensus of the 3 separate member tables was a ‘conditional discharge’
2. Conrad Joseph – 21 yr old – 3 items stolen from different shops, but with foil in bag to prevent security alarms. He has a heroin habit with a £100 debt to his drug supplier, he’s been on drugs since he was 15 and had previous prison sentence, but says he would like to get off the drug habit. The only mitigation was the low value of the goods stolen. Again, the general consensus was either a suspended sentence with rehabilitation or a high value Community order, say 250 hours.
3. Sebastian Rushdie 20 yr old a law student who got involved in drunken assault with a broken bottle in a Night Club. The victim had to have 2 stiches around his eye. The plea is guilty and he was remorseful and had written to the victim apologising and he had no previous form. Our table had much discussion on this case, with wide variations, but John put us out of our misery by stating that this was a serious assault and as such would be referred to the Crown Court.
John mentioned a few other factors such as children of 10 years old are considered to have criminal responsibility, also factors from the family court such as access to children, guardianship, the care system, adoption. The important factor every time is that what is best for the child, first consideration!
Jim did the Vote of thanks expressing how impressed he was with the interest and informative nature of John’s talk and case histories, involving our members. However, if he was on a recruitment mission, he only had to look around the room, but we would still be interested in him organising a visit for our Club. A few questions followed which he handled very well and members showed their appreciation with a boisterous round of applause. AR
'What We Do' Main Pages:
We have now successfully run this event for 10 years. Full reports of each year are available under this main page
morePresidents David's vision for his year and our weekly speaker repoert
moreIt's here that you can read what we've been up to in the last few months. For more information on our work in the local community, with our young people and internationally please access "what we do" section of this web site.
moreThis is a monthly meeting open to visitors from Bingham, Radcliffe, Cotgrave and all villages in surrounding area.
moreThis committee are involved in planning now we can raise funds for our chosen charities
moreIf you like what we do as an organisation and are interested in volunteering with us, keeping up to date with our plans and future events then why not consider signing up as a friend of our Rotary Club
moreOur International Committee is involved with Polio Plus - a Rotary initiative to eradicate Polio, World-wide; Sand dams; Aqua Boxes; Shelter Boxes; Collecting used spectacles, and many other projects
moreHere you can read about the many meetings we've had during our formation as a Rotary Club. The early years are a little short on detail...
more